2011 Lineups

The Pirates have made a handful of moves this off season that will have an impact on what their major league team looks like in 2011. My guess is that the major free agent signings are over on the offensive side. Hopefully the Pirates will add some more pitching, but I'm confident in saying that we can start projecting what the 2011 lineup will look like. I'll go ahead and take a crack at it.

There will certainly be a platoon in right field, and there is now an opportunity for a platoon at first base. My guess is that Garrett Atkins will not get any opportunity to start in the majors, unless there's an injury, so he won't be mentioned in this post. Here's what it looks like, right now:

Pirates vs. right handed pitchers:

1. Andrew McCutchen, CF
2. Jose Tabata, LF
3. Neil Walker, 2B
4. Pedro Alvarez, 3B
5. Garrett Jones, RF
6. Lyle Overbay, 1B
7. Chris Snyder, C
8. Ronny Cedeno, SS
9. Pitcher

Pirates vs. left handed pitchers:

1. Andrew McCutchen, CF
2. Jose Tabata, LF
3. Neil Walker, 2B
4. Pedro Alvarez, 3B
5. Lyle Overbay, 1B
6. Matt Diaz, RF
7. Chris Snyder, C
8. Ronny Cedeno, SS
9. Pitcher

If the Pirates hold on to Ryan Doumit, which doesn't seem very likely, he will probably make a lot of starts at catcher against righties, as well as making a couple starts in right field. There's not a whole lot that will change as the year goes on, in terms of minor leaguers. Last year, we were anticipating the arrivals of Tabata and Alvarez, and were pleasantly surprised with Walker's performance. This year the only guy you can point at that will come from the minors and start in the majors is Chase d'Arnaud. d'Arnaud is no where near the calibur prospect that Tabata and Alvarez were, but if he works out he will certainly be an upgrade from Cedeno.

All-in-all that's a pretty decent lineup, the best the Pirates have had in a long time. We're not gonna be at the top of the league in scoring or anything, but it should be good enough to be competitive. The pitching is still no where near good enough to have the team actually compete in 2011, but it will at least be a better brand of baseball being played.

Comments (7)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
John Lease's avatar

John Lease · 745 weeks ago

It still blows, unfortunately.
Jim Carson's avatar

Jim Carson · 745 weeks ago

this blog blows as well
I, disagree wiyh your statement yhat Garrett Adkins will not get an oppertunity to start. Against a nasty south-paw he could play either first or third adequately.
Julio Gonzalez's avatar

Julio Gonzalez · 745 weeks ago

The Pirates need more pitching and defense next season in order to play at least around .500 level. Evan Meek is the closer. Alvarez will be the offensive revelation with more than 100 RBI's in 2011. Maybe Doumit is a perfect fit to play for a team in the American League as a DH, C and RF.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
The Bucx need to trade Garrett Jones in addition to Ryan Doumit. Maybe as a package, because Jones looks at too many third strikes and Doumit is ort-injured.
Jack Gill's avatar

Jack Gill · 744 weeks ago

The Pirates need pitching like a razor cut needs a bandaid. They have very little to put on the mound. I would go after either Joe Blanton or Kyle Kendrick of the Phillies, perhaps both of them. I know we would have to sacrifice some young talent, but either of these two guys would be a substantial upgrade over what we have. Pitching wins games and we are in dire need.
While you are certainly right Jack, I don't think it is in the Pirates best interest right now to go after big league pitchers. Even if we would add Blanton and Kendrick, I hardly think it would push us into the playoff race. We need another year of development for our offense and for our young pitchers before we can seriously consider contending.

Also, signing less than spectacular big league pitchers will result in blocking guys in our system that could turn into very good starters; guys that we would have control over for a longer time (e.g. Morton, Lincoln, Owens, Morris). The Pirates need to get all 4 of those guys starts in 2011 to see what they have in them, and signing more big league pitchers that will only be around for 1-2 years will prevent that.

Post a new comment

Comments by